2018 Toyota Prius

As an enthusiast, you probably aren’t a fan of the Prius, but as someone shopping for a hybrid, it’s likely high on your list. With a 1.8-liter four and an electric motor that combine to make 121 hp, the Prius gets 54 mpg city and 50 mpg highway—if you drive it in the most efficient (translation: boring) manner possible. It’s the automotive equivalent of eating your vegetables; an Eco model is available for those looking to really up their green game. It rates at 58 mpg city and 53 mpg highway.